Showing posts with label Bollywood. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bollywood. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 3, 2007

Movie Review: Guru

Guru is the story of Gurukant Desai (Abhishek Bachchan), a street-smart adolescent in a small village in Gujarat, India. After failing his exams in school and yet another tiff with his father, he leaves for Turkey to take up a job there. A few years later, fed up of working for the "goras", he returns to India where he gets married to Sujata (Aishwarya Rai). He uses her dowry to start up a business in polyester. As his business grows, he gets involved in increasingly murky dealings. Eventually, the owner of a newspaper Nanaji(Mithun Chakraborty), who once was like a father to Guru, realizes the extent of corruption prevalent in Guru's company and is determined to bring him to justice with the help of his trusty editor Shyam (Mahadevan). Guru is required to appear before a commission where after a rousing speech, in typical Bollywood candy-floss manner, he is let off with only a minor fine.

As I wrote the above summary, I realized that there really isn't much going on during the almost-3-hour movie. It could have been mind-numbingly boring were it not for Abhishek Bachchan, who really gives a wonderful performance. He effortlessly portrays Guru as a man with naive arrogance, boyish exuberance, steely determination and almost frightening ambition and ruthlessness, and makes him quite likable. Even though there were moments when one could see the Amitabh Bachchan in him (which isn't necessarily a bad thing), one can see that he has come into his own. Aishwarya Rai, for a change, is pretty good as well. She doesn't giggle or ham, and the difference between her in Guru and in Dhoom 2 is remarkable. Mithun Chakraborty and Mahadevan are pretty good. Vidya Balan's character in the movie did not add anything substantial to it and was quite pointless.

AR Rehman's music was pleasing, though a couple of songs were redundant and misplaced. Mani Ratnam has again given us an eminently watchable movie with some stellar performances. While tighter editing would have helped, Guru is one of the better Bollywood movies I've watched in a long time.

Rating: ***

[Rating Scale:
****: What a fantastic movie!
*** : Pretty good. Could be better, but not bad at all.
** : Below average. Snooze fest.
* : Seriously, what were they thinking? How dare they put their audience through such hell? This movie should really never have been made. I want my money back!]

Friday, March 30, 2007

Kunal Kohli's MSN columns

I recently came across these articles by Kunal Kohli, a Bollywood director from the Johar-Chopra camp, who has on MSN a column imaginatively called "The Kunal Kohli Column":
http://content.msn.co.in/Lifestyle/Moreonlifestyle/LifestyleIS_1242.htm
http://content.msn.co.in/Entertainment/Bollywood/special_kunalkohli_column.htm
Reading these articles just reinforced the notion that the Bollywood folk have distressingly been placed on pedestals, resulting in gigantic egos and are very much in need of a reality check.

In his first article, he describes how he had to re-evaluate the movie awards system in Bollywood when his movie Fanaa was not nominated for Best Film and he was not nominated for Best Director at the Screen and Filmfare awards. I congratulate him on realizing at last that in a country where every TV channel and unhealthy food brand has its own movie award, it really isn't much of an honor to win one of them. What I am amazed at is that it was his exclusion from the awards that led him to this introspection and subsequent conclusion. He clearly thinks so highly of himself and his movie that by not nominating him, these awards have opened his eyes and proved their worthlessness to him!

The second article would be fantastic were it a tongue-in-cheek article. Mr. Kohli is unfortunately, perfectly serious. The basic premise is that Bollywood has the potential to make a Grand Canyon sized mark in the global market, and eventually to buy out Hollywood. We have a lot of new and bright film makers with fresh ideas that would have universal appeal. I was quite amused to see Hum Tum (his first film) in the examples of movies with an unusual theme. Somehow, I really doubt the Western audience would want to watch Hum Tum when they can watch When Harry Met Sally with the delightful Meg Ryan and Billy Crystal instead. (Hum Tum is a shameless and blatant copy of When Harry Met Sally.) He further states that piracy of Indian movies results in enormous financial losses that could be used to make bigger and better movies. I hate to disillusion Mr. Kohli but the problem in Bollywood is a paucity of interesting stories, skilled directors and actors who do not ham their way to the end of each film. Regrettably, injecting more money into each movie is not the solution. Maybe I'm being myopic and/or pessimistic, but an Indian film maker making something on the scale of Lord of the Rings or even Spiderman is really quite inconceivable. They cannot even do a decent job of something like Salaam-e-Ishq. The second problem is that in Bollywood, bigger and better is defined as having more glitz and glamor, a la Dhoom 2, which I feel is the last thing we need. Indeed, if the movies got any glossier, we'd need sunglasses just to watch them. Finally, Bollywood movies in general tend to be so disappointing, that the audience feels loath to spend money on the tickets. So while I'm not advocating piracy in any way, I do think the industry needs to realize its responsibility to give us something watchable and enjoyable, and stop blaming us for their shortcomings.

I am also continually amazed at how much Bollywood overestimates the interest that Western society has in our movies. Indian movies make the kind of money they do abroad because of South Asians living abroad. Period. That is because these folks will watch any kind of Hindi movie, no matter how outlandish, garish or silly, because it re-connects them for a couple of hours to their home in India that they left behind. There is a very small group of westerners who will watch some of our movies, much like Chinese or Spanish movies, and we will lose this audience if we don't focus more on substance and less on barely-there stories and clothes.

Buy out Hollywood indeed! Just how deluded are these guys in Mumbai's Tinseltown? But enough about Kunal Kohli and his self-indulgent, self-aggrandizing and utterly misguided comments. I really should get back to work now.